Lead follow-up: how fast to respond and how many times to follow up

In a 2024 test, only 33% of 500 law firms answered an emailed inquiry. A lead who never hears back doesn't say no. They hire whoever answered.

5 free fixes you can do today are further down this page.
  • Make every web inquiry impossible to miss
  • Copy a second person on every inquiry
  • Write the first reply and the follow-ups once
  • Put a booking link in the first reply
  • Find the leads that fell through

Lead follow-up by the numbers

33%

of 500 law firms answered an emailed inquiry in 2024, down from 40% in 2019.

Clio Legal Trends Report, 2024
48%

of those firms couldn't be reached by phone at all.

Clio Legal Trends Report, 2024
83%

of customers expect to engage with someone immediately when they contact a company.

Salesforce State of the Connected Customer, 2020
8 in 10

U.S. adults don't usually answer a call from a number they don't know.

Pew Research Center, 2020

Why it matters

People who fill in your form want an answer now. In a 2020 Salesforce survey of 12,000 consumers and 3,600 business buyers, 83% said they expect to engage with someone immediately when they contact a company. While your reply waits, they keep shopping.

Even busy, established firms are slow to answer. In a 2024 test of 500 law firms, only 33% answered an emailed inquiry, down from 40% in 2019. On the phone, 48% couldn't be reached at all. These are firms whose whole business is new clients.

One try isn't follow-up. In a 2020 Pew Research Center survey, 8 in 10 U.S. adults said they don't usually answer calls from numbers they don't know. So the first call often goes to voicemail, and the text and the second and third touch are what reach them.

Signs you have this problem

  • Fill in your own website form at 8pm. Time how long until someone replies.
  • Pull your last 20 inquiries. For each one, write down the time to first reply and how many times you followed up.
  • Count the quotes or estimates you sent in the last 60 days that got no answer. How many got a second touch?
  • Ask who answers new inquiries when you're on a job or on vacation. If the answer is nobody, that's the gap.
  • Look at last month's inquiries and mark which ones became paying jobs. If you can't tell, you can't see where they drop off.

Four places leads go cold

The web form

A form comes in as an email, and nobody sees it until hours later.

Today
Where does a form on your website go when someone sends it?
Where it sticks
Who checks that inbox, and how often?
What it costs
How many inquiries last month waited more than a day for a reply?
If it were solved
If every form got a reply in minutes, who would handle the answers?

The first call

You call back once, it goes to voicemail, and the lead sits there.

Today
When you call a new lead back, how often do they pick up?
Where it sticks
What happens after the first call goes to voicemail?
What it costs
How many leads last month did you never reach at all?
If it were solved
If a text went out right after every missed callback, how many more would you reach?

The quote that went quiet

An estimate goes out and nobody follows up when the customer doesn't answer.

Today
What do you do after you send a quote?
Where it sticks
How long before someone checks back on it, if anyone does?
What it costs
What were the quotes from the last 60 days with no answer worth?
If it were solved
If every quiet quote got two more follow-ups, which ones would you want back?

Busy weeks

Follow-up happens on slow weeks and stops when you're slammed.

Today
Who sends follow-ups when you're on a job or on vacation?
Where it sticks
Which follow-ups get skipped first when the week gets busy?
What it costs
How many leads from a busy month never got a second touch?
If it were solved
If follow-ups went out on time every week, what would you do with the time you spend chasing?

Simple things to do this week

  1. Make every web inquiry impossible to miss

    Form emails get buried under everything else. Give them their own label and a star.

    1. In Gmail, click Show search options in the search box, enter the address your form sends from, then click Create filter.
    2. Choose to apply a new label called Leads and to star it, then click Create filter. In Outlook, set up a rule that flags the same emails.
  2. Copy a second person on every inquiry

    When you're on a job, someone else should see the lead and answer it.

    1. In Gmail, click Settings, then See all settings, then Forwarding and POP/IMAP, then Add a forwarding address. They'll get a link to confirm it.
    2. Then make a filter for your form emails and choose Forward it to that address, so only leads get forwarded.
  3. Write the first reply and the follow-ups once

    Call first. If they don't pick up, send the first reply, then follow up on day 1, day 3 and day 7.

    1. In Gmail, click Settings, then See all settings, then Advanced. Next to Templates, click Enable and save.
    2. Write this, then click More options, then Templates, then Save draft as template:Hi [name], this is [your name] at [your business]. Got your request about [job] and just tried to call. What's a good time to talk today? You can also pick a time here: [booking link]
    3. Save a second template for the follow-ups:Hi [name], following up on [job]. Do you still need help with it? Just reply here and I'll take it from there.
  4. Put a booking link in the first reply

    A link to pick a time ends phone tag before it starts.

    1. In Google Calendar, click Create, then Appointment schedule. Set the hours you take calls or visits and save. Some features need a paid Google plan.
    2. Copy the link to your booking page and paste it into your first-reply template.
  5. Find the leads that fell through

    Once a month, look back for inquiries that never got a second touch.

    1. In the Gmail search box, type this:label:leads newer_than:30d
    2. Open each one and check whether you replied and followed up. Send the follow-up template to every one that went quiet.

What we set up

The fixes above work when someone sends every follow-up by hand. This sends them on time on the busy weeks too.

A reply right away

Every new inquiry gets a text and an email from your business.

Follow-ups on a schedule

If they don't answer, the next follow-ups go out over the following days.

Stops when they reply

The moment they answer, the follow-ups stop and you take it from there.

Booked on your calendar

When they're ready, they pick a time and it lands on your calendar.

7 days

Typical turnaround, from access to live.

  1. Discovery call

    Free · 30 minutes

    Walk us through a normal week. You leave with the first fix, ranked.

  2. Build and go live

    Typically 7 days

    Set up on your phone number, forms and calendar. Nothing new for your staff to learn.

  3. Report and tune

    Every month

    You see what it handled and booked. We fix what is underperforming.

Questions owners ask

How quickly should you respond to a new lead?

As fast as you can, in minutes if it's during business hours. In a 2020 Salesforce survey, 83% of customers said they expect to engage with someone immediately when they contact a company. You don't need a perfect answer first. A short reply that says you got it and asks one question keeps them from filling in the next form on the list.

How many times should you follow up with a lead?

More than once. Many people don't answer the first message, because they're busy, not because they said no. A simple plan is a call and a text the same day, then a follow-up on day 1, day 3 and day 7. Stop when they reply, when they say no, or after the last one. Keep each message short and easy to answer.

Should I call, text or email a new lead?

Call first, then text if they don't pick up. In a 2020 Pew Research Center survey, 8 in 10 U.S. adults said they don't usually answer calls from numbers they don't know, so your first call may go to voicemail. A text right after lets them answer when they're free. Email works best for longer details, like a quote.

Will automated follow-up annoy people?

Not when it's short and stops at the right time. They asked you for help, so they expect to hear back. What bothers people is a message that keeps coming after they already answered, or a sales pitch they never asked for. Write it like you'd text a customer yourself, and make sure every message stops the moment they reply.

What should I do when a lead stops answering?

Send one last message that is easy to answer with a yes or a no. Something like: "Hi Sam, should I keep your request open, or did you get it handled?" People who went quiet often answer that one, and a clear no is better than wondering. Then mark the lead closed so it stops taking up your time.

How much does lead follow-up cost?

It depends on how many inquiries you get and where they come from, like your website form, Google or your booking software. On a free 30-minute discovery call, Chad looks at how leads come in today and gives you a price. If the free fixes on this page are enough, you don't need us for this one.

Get a free audit of your business

Chad looks at how customers find you and how they reach you, then emails you what he finds.

  • How you show up on Google next to the businesses near you
  • How fast your website loads on a phone
  • Where calls, texts and forms slip through
  • Free fixes you can do yourself this week

Would it be a bad idea to look at your last 20 leads together?

30 minutes with Chad. You leave with the first fix, ranked, whether or not we build it.

Book a discovery call