Past customers: how to win them back and get more referrals

A reminder text brought back 6.8% more past customers in a 2020 study of 689,693 pharmacy patients. The people who already paid you once are the easiest ones to hear from again.

5 free fixes you can do today are further down this page.
  • Put past customers in one list
  • Send one personal email, saved as a template
  • Text by hand, only to people who said texts are fine
  • Put the next due date on your calendar
  • Ask for one referral, by type of person

Past customers by the numbers

6.8%

more past customers came back after a reminder text, compared with no text.

Milkman et al., PNAS, study run 2020
78%

of U.S. adults say personal messages make them more likely to buy again.

McKinsey & Company, 2021
88%

of people trust recommendations from people they know more than any other channel.

Nielsen Trust in Advertising, 2021 (global)
52%

of U.S. consumers stopped buying from a brand after a bad experience with its products or services.

PwC Customer Experience Survey, 2025
29%

stopped because of poor customer experience, online or in person.

PwC, 2025

Why it matters

Past customers already know your work and your prices. When they drift away, a short reminder at the right time can bring them back. In a 2020 field study of 689,693 Walmart pharmacy patients who had a flu shot there the year before and had agreed to get texts, a reminder text raised the share who came back by 6.8% over sending nothing.

The message has to sound like it came from you. In a 2021 McKinsey survey of 1,013 U.S. adults, 78% said personal messages made them more likely to buy again. A note with their name and the job you did beats a coupon sent to everyone.

Happy customers are also your best source of new ones. In Nielsen's 2021 survey of more than 40,000 people worldwide, 88% said they trust recommendations from people they know more than any other channel. The ask just has to be specific and come right after a good visit.

Signs you have this problem

  • Pull everyone who paid you 12 to 24 months ago. Count how many have not been back.
  • Set a timer for 10 minutes and try to make a list of past customers with a phone number or email. Can you finish before it goes off?
  • Think of the last time you reached out to a past customer before they called you. If you can't remember, nobody is doing it.
  • Look at the jobs you finished a year ago. How many are due again now, like an annual service or a renewal, and have those customers heard from you?
  • Count how many of last quarter's new customers came from a referral. If you don't know, that is a sign too.

Four places past customers slip away

After the last invoice

The job is done, the bill is paid, and nobody plans the next visit.

Today
What happens with a customer after the last invoice is paid?
Where it sticks
Who decides when they should hear from you next?
What it costs
How many one-time customers from last year never came back?
If it were solved
If every customer heard from you when they were due, who would book those jobs?

When something comes due

Tune-ups, cleanings, check-ups and renewals come due, and the customer forgets.

Today
Which of your jobs need doing again, and how often?
Where it sticks
Where do you keep track of who is due and when?
What it costs
How many customers were due last season and booked with someone else, or not at all?
If it were solved
If a reminder went out on the right week for each one, how full would your slow months be?

After a bad visit

A customer who had one bad experience goes quiet, and nobody notices.

Today
How do you find out when a customer was unhappy?
Where it sticks
Who follows up after a complaint, and how fast?
What it costs
How many regulars stopped coming last year without saying why?
If it were solved
If you heard about a bad visit the same week, what would you do to make it right?

The referral moment

A happy customer would send a friend, but nobody asks.

Today
When does a customer tell you they're happy with the work?
Where it sticks
What do you say then, if anything, about referrals?
What it costs
How many of last quarter's new customers came from a referral?
If it were solved
If every happy customer got one specific ask, who would you want them to send?

Simple things to do this week

  1. Put past customers in one list

    You can't bring people back if their names are spread across invoices, texts and old emails.

    1. Export past customers from your invoicing or booking tool, or group them in Google Contacts. Go to Google Contacts, and next to Labels on the left, click Create label. Name it, then click Save.
    2. Check the boxes next to your past customers, click Manage labels at the top, pick the label and click Apply.
  2. Send one personal email, saved as a template

    Write one note with a real reason to come back, then send it one person at a time, by name.

    1. In Gmail on a computer, click Settings, then See all settings, then Advanced. Next to Templates, click Enable, then Save Changes.
    2. Write the note in a new email, then click More options, then Templates, then Save draft as template. Start from this:Hi [name], it's [your name] at [your business]. We [did the job] for you about a year ago, and [it's usually due again / the season is coming up]. Want me to put you on the schedule? If you'd rather not get notes like this, just reply and tell me.
    3. Put your business address in your email signature, and stop writing to anyone who asks.
  3. Text by hand, only to people who said texts are fine

    A text you type yourself to a customer who gave you their number reads like a person, because it is one.

    1. Send it one at a time from your phone:Hi [name], it's [your name] at [your business]. It's been a while since we [did the job]. Want me to get you on the schedule? Reply STOP and I won't text again.
    2. Before you load a list into any texting tool, make sure each person agreed in writing to get marketing texts from you. Anyone who replies STOP comes off the list that day.
  4. Put the next due date on your calendar

    When a job ends, decide when that customer will need you next, and write it down while you know.

    1. Add a calendar event on the day they'll be due again, like a filter change, an annual service or a lease renewal. Put their name, number and what's due in the event.
    2. When the event comes up, send the email or text above.
  5. Ask for one referral, by type of person

    "Tell your friends" is easy to ignore. A question about one kind of person is easy to answer.

    1. Ask right after a good visit, at the same time you ask for a review:Glad it went well. Do you know anyone else [on your street / at your office] who needs [the service]? I'd take good care of them.

What we set up

The fixes above work in the weeks you have time for them. This keeps them going in the busy weeks, to the customers who said yes to hearing from you.

Win-back texts

Past customers who haven't been back get a short, personal text with a reason to return.

Reminders on time

Seasonal and renewal reminders go out when each customer is due, not when you remember.

Referral asks

Happy customers get a specific referral ask at the right moment, right after a good visit.

Stop means stop

Anyone who opts out comes off the list and never gets another text.

7 days

Typical turnaround, from access to live.

  1. Discovery call

    Free · 30 minutes

    Walk us through a normal week. You leave with the first fix, ranked.

  2. Build and go live

    Typically 7 days

    Set up on your phone number, forms and calendar. Nothing new for your staff to learn.

  3. Report and tune

    Every month

    You see what it handled and booked. We fix what is underperforming.

Questions owners ask

How do you win back customers who stopped coming?

Start with the ones who left on good terms. Make one list, then reach out one at a time with a real reason to come back, like a service that is due or a season that is starting. Use their name and mention the work you did. Some of them never meant to leave. They just stopped thinking about you, and a short, friendly note puts you back on their mind.

What should a win-back message say?

Keep it short and personal. Say who you are, what you did for them and when, and why now is a good time, like the season or a service that's due. Then ask one easy question, such as "Want me to put you on the schedule?" Skip the long sales pitch. End with an easy way to opt out, so they never feel trapped.

Should I offer a discount to win back old customers?

Usually not. A discount out of nowhere can tell people you're slow or that your prices had room in them, and it trains them to wait for the next one. A real reason works better: the service is due, the season is turning, or you have a new option they asked about before. Save discounts for a real event, not as the reason you're writing.

Is it legal to text past customers?

The rules for marketing texts are strict. Before you send them from any texting tool, get each person's written OK to receive marketing texts from you, and give them an easy way out, like replying STOP. Take anyone who opts out off the list right away. Some states add their own rules, so a lawyer can tell you what applies where you are.

How often should I contact past customers?

Only when you have a real reason. That might be a service coming due, a season starting, a renewal date or something new you now offer. For most service businesses that is a few times a year, not every week. If a customer replies that they're all set or asks you to stop, respect it and mark it on their record.

How much does it cost?

It depends on how many past customers you have, where their records live today and how often they need you. On a free 30-minute discovery call, Chad looks at your customer list and how you reach people now, and gives you a price. If the free fixes on this page are enough, you don't need us for this one.

Get a free audit of your business

Chad looks at how customers find you and how they reach you, then emails you what he finds.

  • How you show up on Google next to the businesses near you
  • How fast your website loads on a phone
  • Where calls, texts and forms slip through
  • Free fixes you can do yourself this week

Would it be a bad idea to look at your past customer list together?

A Charlotte gym signed 3x in memberships for every $1 it spent with us.

30 minutes with Chad. You leave with the first fix, ranked, whether or not we build it.

Book a discovery call